Intellectual Consistency on the Left? Now That’s What I Call Progress

work-in-progressEven before recent health care nullification efforts, writers at the Tenth Amendment Center were calling for a federalism-driven debate on standard liberal issues like gay marriage, REAL ID, and medical marijuana. Finally, it seems, someone on the Left has recognized the wisdom of that strategy.

I almost fell out of my chair this morning upon reading a post on the popular progressive blog FireDogLake:

…progressives need to support the Arizona Health Care Freedom Act.

Protecting Americans from corporatist greed and influence should be at the heart of what we are about.

And– it helped get Obama elected– no mandates. period. And no nut job at Aetna or in the government should keep you from spending your own money on legal health care.

Supporters have been accused of “nullification” — a not subtle claim that somehow if these efforts succeed, and are contrary to federal health care law (in both House and Senate versions), supporters seek a pre-civil war mentality.

And, of course, there is federal supremacy– so the efforts are futile.

But, what of DOMA? Aren’t Progressives in favor of same sex marriage via state efforts the same? Umm, yes.

But what of federal drug laws? Aren’t Progressives in favor of liberal medical marijuana state laws the same? Umm, yes.

But what of the right to die laws like in Oregon? The SCOTUS has actually decided IN FAVOR of Oregon in this state’s rights case… even though there are federal laws against it.

Progressives must be consistent intellectually— especially when conservatives are not. [emphasis added]

Support the Health Care Freedom Act in Arizona and around the country.

It is hard to overstate the significance of this point. If the Left as well as the Right can start to see that decentralization of power through federalism is the answer to intractable partisan gridlock and divisive culture wars, the tenthers can join forces with those on both sides who only desire more freedom and prosperity.

And then Washington’s corrupt, corporatist, top-down power structure will really be in trouble.

Enjoyed This Post?

We cannot succeed without your help, as we will never accept government grants or handouts. Please help us by investing in the Constitution and freedom today!

Enjoyed This Post?

,

1 comments
Steve
Steve

I think you're on to something. From the left here, I couldn't agree more. I think what everyone's really tired of in this country is having to come to this huge consensus on every issue before moving forward. States are supposed to be incubators of new ideas, new ways of approaching problems and finding solutions. But the right puts its stranglehold on states just as the left puts its strangehold on them as well. I think a lot of people are realizing this now though... libertarianism, as an idea, can be just as easily paired with a left-wing philosophy as it has traditionally been paired with a right-wing philosophy. If there's any common ground we can find between us, I think it's that we'd all like to be left alone to choose our own paths. Decentralization is key to that opportunity. And maybe if both sides can test out their ideas and see if they're good or bad on a smaller scale, it will help the country as a whole to determine better policies, and get past all the rhetoric. We talk and we talk and we talk but no one knows because no one can actually try anything out. All the good bills get ruined in endless negotiation and it just manufactures bribes and quid pro quos. Here here.

Trackbacks

  1. Social comments and analytics for this post…

    This post was mentioned on Twitter by presidanny: RT @TenthAmendment: #10th: Intellectual Consistency on the Left? Now That’s What I Call Progress http://bit.ly/b6pkCG