The Washington Post Editorial Board: Frustration over stalled immigration action doesn’t mean Obama can act unilaterally. From the conclusion:
The right response to the collapse of the U.S. immigration system is for Congress to fix the law. The House had a vehicle to do just that by taking up the legislation passed by the Senate last year. But it does not follow that Congress can be ignored based on its failure to act. The right response to lawmakers who won’t solve the immigration mess is to replace them with ones who will.
Via Josh Blackman, who outlines his views here. Also via Josh Blackman, at Slate, Reihan Salam: Gridlock is Good — When House Republicans stand in the way of President Obama, it means they’re taking their constitutional duties seriously.
And a further related post from Josh Blackman: 1992 OLC Memo: President, In Face of Senate Filibuster, Should Not Use Unilateral Authority to Change Unambiguous Law.
In the New Republic, Eric Posner has a somewhat contrary view: Obama Is Legally Allowed to Enforce—or Not Enforce—the Law — with which, surprisingly, I agree a good bit (more on that later). But there’s this:
If Congress cannot pass any laws because of gridlock, then it has violated its obligations under the Constitution, and accordingly the president has the right to use his enforcement powers to implement policies that serve the public interest.
Wrong. Congress has no “obligations under the Constitution” to pass laws (subject perhaps to a few specific exceptions that aren’t relevant to immigration or anything else that Professor Posner is talking about). Congress has the power to pass laws. But it also has the power to decide not to pass laws. That Congress fails to pass laws that President Obama or Eric Posner thinks are needful only proves that Congress has a different view, not that something subtlely unconstitutional, justifying extra-constitutional solutions, is afoot.
Latest posts by Michael D. Ramsey (see all)
- Boehner’s Plan for Netanyahu to Address Congress is Unconstitutional - January 25, 2015
- The Original Meaning of “Legislature” - September 22, 2014
- Originalism and the Two Narratives of Halbig - September 9, 2014