ALBANY, N.Y. (Dec. 20, 2021) – A bill filed in the New York Senate would allow customers to opt out of installing “smart meter” technology on their homes and businesses. Passage of this bill would enable residents in these states to protect their own privacy, and it would take a step toward blocking a federal program in effect.

Senator Comrie (D) introduced Senate Bill 5510 (SB5510) earlier this year. The bill would restrict the use of advanced metering infrastructure devices by electric, gas, and water-works corporations, and would also allow citizens to decline the use of smart meters.

Smart meters monitor home energy usage in minute detail in real-time. The devices transmit data to the utility company where it gets stored in databases. Anybody with access to the data can download it for analysts. Without specific criteria limiting access to the data, these devices create significant privacy issues. Smart meters can also be used to remotely limit power usage during peak hours.

Under the proposed law, utility companies would be required to give a 90-day notice of installation to customers, who may then opt out without penalty.

“An electric and/or gas corporation may not install a two-way smart meter on a customer’s premises that is assigned to such customer’s account unless it shall provide written notice to the customer no less than ninety days prior to the scheduled installation of such meter. Such notice shall provide that the customer shall have the right to decline his or her electric and/or gas corporation from installing a two-way smart meter with no fee, penalty or service charge; the customer may, at any point during a period of three hundred sixty-five days following the installation of a two-way smart meter, require the removal of such device with no fee, penalty or service charge”

Privacy Concerns

The proliferation of smart meters creates significant privacy concerns.

SmartGridAwareness.org lists two broad ways this technology threatens individual privacy.

  • Smart meters will reveal the activities of people inside of a home by measuring their electricity, gas, or water usage frequently over time.
  • inadequate cybersecurity measures surrounding the digital transmission of smart meter data will expose it to misuse by authorized and unauthorized users of the data.

The Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC) lists a number of specific potential privacy issues, including identity theft, the ability to determine personal behavior patterns, the ability to perform real-time surveillance, reveal activities through the analysis of residual data, and behavior tracking. According to EPIC, “If plans for national or transnational electric utility smart grid systems proceed as currently proposed these far-reaching networks will enable data collection and sharing across platforms and great distances.”

The data collected can tell anybody who holds it a great deal about what goes on inside a home. It can reveal when residents are at home, asleep, or on vacation. It can also pinpoint “unusual” energy use, and could someday serve to help enforce “energy usage” regulations. The ACLU summarised the privacy issues surrounding smart meters in a recent report.

“The temptation to use the information that will be collected from customers for something other than managing electrical loads will be strong – as it has been for cell phone tracking data and GPS information. Police may want to know your general comings and goings or whether you’re growing marijuana in your basement under grow lights. Advertisers will want the information to sell you a new washing machine to replace the energy hog you got as a wedding present 20 years ago. Information flowing in a smart grid will become more and more ‘granular’ as the system develops.”

The privacy issues aren’t merely theoretical. According to information obtained by the California ACLU, utility companies in the state have disclosed information gathered by smart meters on thousands of customers. San Diego Gas and Electric alone disclosed data on more than 4,000 customers. The vast majority of disclosures were in response to subpoenas by government agencies “often in drug enforcement cases or efforts to find specific individuals,” according to SFGate.

“Mark Toney, executive director of the Utility Reform Network watchdog group, said the sheer number of data disclosures made by SDG&E raised the possibility that government agencies wanted to sift through large amounts of data looking for patterns, rather than conducting targeted investigations.”

No Smart Meter, No Data

Refusing to allow a smart meter on your property is the only sure-fire way to ensure your energy use data won’t fall into the hands of government agents or private marketers or end up stored in some kind of government database. Passage of SB5510 would make opting out a legal option for New Yorkers and give them control over their own privacy.

Impact on Federal Program

The federal government serves as a major source of funding for smart meters. A 2009 program through the U.S. Department of Energy distributed $4.5 billion for smart grid technology. The initial projects were expected to fund the installation of 1.8 million smart meters over three years.

The federal government lacks any constitutional authority to fund smart grid technology. The easiest way to nullify such programs is to simply not participate. This legislation would make that possible. If enough states pass similar legislation, and enough people opt out, the program will go nowhere.

We’ve seen a similar opt-out movement undermining Common Core in New York. Opting out follows a strategy James Madison advised in Federalist #46. “Refusal to cooperate with officers of the Union” provides a powerful means to fight back against government overreach. Such actions in multiple states would likely be effective in bringing down federal smart meter programs.

WHAT’S NEXT

SB5510 has been referred to the Senate Energy and Telecommunications Committee where it must pass with a majority vote before it can continue on in the legislative process.

The 10th Amendment

“The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.”

LEARN MORE

01

Featured Articles

On the Constitution, history, the founders, and analysis of current events.

featured articles

02

Tenther Blog and News

Nullification news, quick takes, history, interviews, podcasts and much more.

tenther blog

03

State of the Nullification Movement

108 pages. History, constitutionality, and application today.

get the report

01

Path to Liberty

Our flagship podcast. Michael Boldin on the constitution, history, and strategy for liberty today

path to liberty

02

Maharrey Minute

The title says it all. Mike Maharrey with a 1 minute take on issues under a 10th Amendment lens. maharrey minute

Tenther Essentials

2-4 minute videos on key Constitutional issues - history, and application today

TENTHER ESSENTIALS

Join TAC, Support Liberty!

Nothing helps us get the job done more than the financial support of our members, from just $2/month!

JOIN TAC

01

The 10th Amendment

History, meaning, and purpose - the "Foundation of the Constitution."

10th Amendment

03

Nullification

Get an overview of the principles, background, and application in history - and today.

nullification