Here’s what Paul Armentano and Richard Evans have to say about this week’s vote on Prop 19:
Here are two little-known fact about Proposition 19, the California marijuana legalization initiative on this November’s ballot. This isn’t the first time California voters have had the opportunity to repeal their state prohibition laws, nor is it the first time a state has shifted an enforcement burden unto the federal government.
In 1920, commerce in alcohol was outlawed nationally by the 18th Amendment and the federal Volstead Act, and by the laws of most states. Yet in 1932 Californians voted 3 to 1 to repeal the ban on alcohol prohibition, leaving production, distribution and sale of alcohol unregulated under state law. Voters decided: If the federal government believes so strongly in prohibition, then let them – and them alone – be responsible for enforcing it.
Californians weren’t alone in their rejection of federal prohibition. In total, eleven U.S. states eventually elected to opt out of this failing and ultimately doomed federal policy. In New York, Gov. Al Smith signed legislation repealing the state’s prohibitions on booze nearly ten years earlier, in 1923. New Yorkers were horrified with the rising level of prohibition-related crime taking place in their state among suppliers and distributors, as well as with the bilious brew that was being produced on the black market. The Governor declared that his signature produced no conflict with federal law, and explained how the cause of prohibition enforcement – and thus temperance itself – would be strengthened, not weakened, by the measure.
“The mere omission to maintain a state statute in no way abrogates a federal statute,” he instructed. “Repeal … will not make legal a single act which was [previously] illegal.”
Latest posts by Michael Boldin (see all)
- Guns and Weed: My Interview with CQ Weekly Magazine - September 22, 2014
- Pres. Obama Couldn’t be More Wrong About the Constitution - September 18, 2014
- James Madison on the dangers of expanded power due to war - September 15, 2014